
BEN FRENCH
 Ben French
WWI Draft Registration Card 12th September 1918 One of the many fascinating stories Jelly Roll Morton narrated on the Library of Congress recordings was about his travels with a would-be tough man from Jackson, the capital of Mississippi, who went by the name of Jack the Bear. Jelly Roll said that he “first went to Memphis around nineteen eight, possibly the earliest part of the year.” [1664-B] However, it was probably, on the basis of the information presented below, the early part of 1911. Starting from Jackson, the unlikely pair moved on to the Mississippi towns of Yazoo, then to Clarksdale where they tried peddling a consumption cure made of Coca Cola and salt, [1665-A] and on to Helena, Arkansas to board The Natchez for their ultimate destination upriver, Memphis, Tennessee. [1665-B]
Jelly Roll and Jack gravitated towards Beale Street, called the Main Street of Black America and one of the toughest places in the whole South, and ended up in the Monarch Club, like lambs to the slaughter, for their confrontation with Bad Sam, the toughest man in Memphis who ran the dice game and acted as bouncer, and Benny Frenchy, the best pianist in the whole state of Tennessee. [1666-A] In the event, Jelly Roll easily overcame Benny’s playing, which he imitated in an exaggerated fashion for the record, with one of his hot stomps and brought the house down singing and playing a sentimental song [1666-B] called All That I Ask Is Love (words by Edgar Selden, music by Herbert Ingraham) published in 1910. Jack the Bear, however, quickly disappeared from the scene.
Benny Frenchy was, in reality, Ben (or Benny) French, and we were able to locate his World War I Draft Card together with census records from 1920 and 1930 which list his occupation as a musician, and leave no doubt whatsoever that he was the pianist at the Monarch. According to the draft card, Ben was born on 16th February 1882, and was, like Jelly Roll and Sam Davis, tall and slender. The entry for him in the 1920 U.S. Census at 395 South Turley Street, Memphis indicates that he was a mulatto, born in Tennessee. His age in both the 1920 U.S. Census and the 1930 U.S. Census is consistent with a birth year of 1882.
That Ben French was well known as a pianist in Memphis is attested by W. C. Handy. In his fine autobiography, Handy notated French’s style of playing, and wrote, under the heading “At the Monarch”:
“The following style of piano playing, by Benny French and Sonny Butts at the Monarch on Beale Street, was my source of inspiration for the treatment given in the piano copies of Beale Street Blues, Yellow Dog Blues, and a few others. The style is theirs; the tune is mine.” [FOB 152]
Handy gave a further example of French’s influence in the introduction and verse of his 1917 publication of Beale Street Blues. [FOB 155] The correct name of Beale Street was actually “Beale Avenue” which was written on the draft card as the location of Benny’s place of employment (317 Beale Avenue), although it was almost universally referred to as Beale Street, apart from entries in census and other official records.
The official name of the Monarch was the Monarch Club. Jelly Roll referred to it on the Library of Congress recordings as the Monarch saloon (note the lower case “s”), because that is what it was. To my knowledge, the word “saloon” never formed part of the name of the place, and this is borne out by Handy’s reference to it above and other references by Jelly Roll himself. The Monarch was built by Jim (James) Kinnane in 1910 at a cost of $20,000 and was located at 340 Beale Street. It was considered the finest gambling parlour in the South with its mirror-walled lobby and fine décor. Kinnane, born in Memphis in 1867 of Irish immigrant parents, was known as the “Czar of the Memphis Underworld,” and owned a string of gambling joints in the Beale Street precinct. It was said the Monarch was fitted with trap doors and secret exits, in case of a police raid. However, it is doubtful if these emergency exits were often used, for Jim’s sister, Josephine, was married to John Brennan, for many years a captain on the Memphis police force. Jim Kinnane told the census-taker in 1910 that his occupation was a self-employed capitalist, one of many unusual occupations recorded in census records. Although he owned the Monarch, it appears that it was managed by another tough Irishman, Mike Haggerty.
The name of Jim Kinnane has been immortalised by several blues singers: Memphis Minnie in her 1930 RCA recording of Four Women Blues, “Mississippi” Joe Callicot and also Walter “Furry” Lewis in the topical Lost My Money in Jim Kinnane’s, and Robert Wilkins, who gave up the blues life after his experiences on Beale Street to become a minister of religion, in his Old Jim Canan’s (a phonetic spelling of the name).
The end of Bad Sam was documented by a most unlikely source, an English Army Major who visited Memphis and Beale Street in 1937. The Major was escorted on a guided tour of Beale Street by a large and friendly police officer who had witnessed the violent scenes of many of the Beale Street gambling dens. When they visited the Monarch, the police officer recounted the story of Bad Sam who had been a bouncer at the club for many years. It was a rule of the club that no fighting was allowed under any circumstances. In a gambling dispute, Bad Sam knocked another man down, and the manager, presumably Mike Haggerty, shot Sam, who drew his pistol and fired back. Neither of them survived the incident. [CEM 123]
As for Benny French, he continued on in the music world in the Beale Street precinct of Memphis, not as a soloist, but as a pianist in an orchestra, according to both the 1920 and the 1930 U.S. Census. The memory of Bad Sam and Benny Frenchy was perpetuated by Jelly Roll’s narrative for the Library of Congress, but also helped by The Record Changer magazine, which for a time featured three guest columnists commenting on current events in the jazz world, each writing under a pseudonym drawn from the characters in the Library of Congress recordings, with an appropriate cartoon image at the beginning of each column: Bad Sam, Benny Frenchy and Aaron Harris. [PH 30] © March 2008 Peter Hanley
|